When a freestyle dancer starts making odd ‘rhythmic spasms,’ the judges on ‘America’s Got Talent’ get a little bit of a shock.

Simon Cowell, who missed much of Season 15 after breaking his back in a bizarre bike accident, returned to his

regular panelist position on Tuesday night as America’s Got Talent premiered its 16th season, looking as dapper as ever in his white Bermuda shorts.

Simon Cowell’s co-stars, Sofia Vergara, Heidi Klum, and Howie Mandell, critiqued his hairy legs before moving on to evaluate some actual talent.

‘I mean, I wouldn’t send them to a Mr. Legs contest or anything like that, or to the AGT of legs, but they’re fine,’

Sofia shrugged. At that point, crazy-legged freestyle dancer Keith Apicary took the stage and proved he could have competed for Mr. Legs.